What Fénelon Said About Spiritual Progress That Modern Christians Miss
⏱ 10 min read
You have been measuring your growth by feeling, and the feeling has gone. The hours at devotions used to leave something warm behind them. Now they leave nothing, and the quietness inside you has begun to read like loss — as if you have slipped backward somewhere, taken a wrong turn months ago, and only just noticed. You are not sure, anymore, whether the absence of the old warmth is a small failure on your part or a sign of something larger that you do not have the vocabulary for.
François Fénelon, the seventeenth-century French archbishop of Cambrai, wrote Spiritual Progress for exactly this woman. The book is not a treatise. It is a collection of letters — short pastoral notes Fénelon wrote, often to women in his spiritual care at the French court, in the years when he had been quietly exiled from royal favour for refusing to soften his own contemplative theology. The letters carry the gentleness of a man writing to one soul at a time, in a soft hand, by candlelight. The single thesis underneath the whole correspondence is a thesis modern Christians almost always miss: real growth feels like loss before it feels like gain. The Everspring Bible Study Workbook for Women was built as the daily small home for that slow growth — one short page per evening, room for one honest line, no requirement to produce a feeling. For now, the Fénelon text.
The misreading the modern Christian inherits
The modern Christian inherits a measure of spiritual progress that Fénelon would not recognise. The measure is felt warmth — the emotional confirmation that the devotional hour has worked. When the warmth is present, the modern Christian concludes she is growing. When the warmth is absent, she concludes she has drifted. The whole interior life is being read through a thermometer Fénelon did not believe was the right instrument.
Fénelon’s measure is older, and quieter. The measure is settled love that no longer needs to feel itself in order to be real. The first years of any Christian life, Fénelon would say, are often warm — and the warmth is given by God, not earned. The middle years, the years when the warmth is withdrawn, are not a regression. They are the slow widening of the heart that allows it to love God without payment in feeling, which is the only kind of love mature enough to survive the long stretches of dryness any walking soul will eventually meet.
The measurement error is the problem. The reader who walks into the middle years still holding the thermometer of felt warmth will read every cool reading as a sign of decline. The thermometer was right for the early years. It is the wrong instrument for the second stretch. Fénelon’s whole pastoral move in Spiritual Progress is to gently take the thermometer from her hand and place a quieter instrument in it.
The first passage: vigilance without harshness
“If, then, we never lost sight of the presence of God, we should never cease to watch, and always with a simple, lovely, quiet and disinterested vigilance; while, on the other hand, the watchfulness which is the result of a desire to be assured of our state, is harsh, restless, and full of self.”
— François Fénelon, Spiritual Progress
Read it once. Then read it again, slowly.
Notice the two kinds of watching Fénelon is naming. The first is simple, lovely, quiet and disinterested vigilance — the soul that keeps watch on God Himself, not on its own progress. The second is the watchfulness which is the result of a desire to be assured of our state — the soul that keeps watch on its own thermometer, anxious about its own reading, harsh, restless, and full of self.
The whole modern preoccupation with spiritual progress lives in the second kind of watching. The frequent self-audits. The journal entries that ask am I closer or farther than last month. The half-honest evening counting of how much you have prayed, how much you have read, how present you felt at church. Fénelon would say, gently, that this watching is not progress. It is a quiet kind of self-absorption dressed in devotional clothing. The eye is on the wrong object. The eye is on the self.
The first kind of watching — the simple lovely quiet vigilance — does not measure itself at all. It keeps the gaze on God. Whether the warmth is present or absent is not the soul’s business. The soul’s business is the gaze. The warmth is His to give. Real fenelon spiritual progress begins, almost always, with the soul putting down the thermometer and lifting its eyes again to the One it has been measuring itself in the absence of.
This is the line that re-frames the cool reading. The cool reading is not necessarily decline. The cool reading is often the soul being weaned from the harsh restless full-of-self watching it has been doing — being asked, slowly, to watch Him instead.
The second passage: fidelity without delights
“God does not call you by any lively emotions, and I heartily rejoice at it, if you will but remain faithful; for a fidelity, unsustained by delights, is far purer, and safer from danger, than one accompanied by those tender feelings, which may be seated too exclusively in the imagination.”
— François Fénelon, Spiritual Progress
Read this one twice. God does not call you by any lively emotions, and I heartily rejoice at it.
Notice the gentleness, and the firmness. Fénelon is writing to a woman who has reported, in her last letter to him, that her devotional emotions have flattened — and his pastoral response is not to reassure her that the feelings will come back. His response is to rejoice that the feelings have gone, if you will but remain faithful. The fidelity that survives the withdrawal of feeling is the fidelity Fénelon trusts. The fidelity that depends on the feeling, in his estimation, is seated too exclusively in the imagination — vulnerable, fragile, dependent on a weather it does not control.
This is the line that breaks the modern measurement frame. Fénelon is not saying that warm devotion is bad. He is saying that warm devotion that needs to be warm in order to keep going is structurally weaker than cool devotion that keeps going regardless. The withdrawal of the warmth, in Fénelon’s pastoral reading, is often God’s mercy — the slow strengthening of the soul’s spine by removing the prop the soul had been leaning on.
The woman who reads this and recognises herself in it can take a small steady breath. The flatness of the current devotional season is not regression. It is, possibly, the deepening Fénelon is naming — the slow exchange of fidelity with delights for fidelity without delights, which is the form of devotion that will hold across the rest of her life.
For the daily home this slow exchange needs, the Everspring Bible Study Workbook for Women holds a short page for the unwarm morning, the cool prayer, the small evening sentence written without the old emotional confirmation. The page does not require a feeling. It requires only that the soul show up to it — which is the fidelity Fénelon is asking the woman to keep.
The somatic — the hand on the page
Pause here. Sit somewhere quiet. Put one hand, palm down, lightly on a closed book on your lap — a Bible, a journal, any book. Notice the small habit your body has of waiting for something to happen. The waiting is in the slight forward lean. In the breath being held at the top of the inhale, as though something might arrive that you would need to be ready for.
Let the lean ease. Let the inhale finish. Let the hand on the book be a hand on a book — nothing more. The hand is not waiting for the book to give it a feeling. The hand is just resting on the book, and the book is just under the hand. Simple, lovely, quiet and disinterested vigilance. The body posture of the kind of watching Fénelon is naming.
Stay there for thirty seconds. Then continue reading.
The small somatic is the body’s version of the line. The body that is leaning forward waiting for the warm reading is the body of the harsh restless full-of-self watching. The body that is resting its hand on the book without expectation is the body of the simple lovely quiet watching. The soul follows the body in this. The body’s small un-leaning teaches the soul to un-lean too.
The third passage: peace inside uncertainty
“We court the reproach of Christ Jesus, and dwell in peace though surrounded by uncertainties; the judgments of God do not affright us, for we abandon ourselves to them, imploring his mercy according to our attainments in confidence, sacrifice, and absolute surrender.”
— François Fénelon, Spiritual Progress
Read it slowly. We dwell in peace though surrounded by uncertainties.
This is the passage that names what the second stretch of the Christian life actually feels like. Not certainty. Not the felt assurance of progress. Uncertainty — and a peace that is no longer derived from the certainty but is given inside it, by abandoning ourselves to the judgments of God in confidence, sacrifice, and surrender.
The modern Christian woman, reading this, will recognise the uncertainty Fénelon is naming. The uncertainty about whether she is growing. The uncertainty about whether her prayer is being heard. The uncertainty about whether the dryness is a season or a permanent state. Fénelon’s pastoral reply is not to resolve the uncertainty. His reply is to teach her to dwell in peace inside it. The peace is the new instrument. The thermometer is gone. The peace is what replaces it.
The peace is not a feeling either, exactly. The peace is the settled posture of the soul that has handed itself over — abandoned itself — to a God whose judgments it does not always understand and does not need to. The peace is built by the daily small handing-over, the small repeated I do not need to know; I will keep walking, the slow abandonment of the need for the felt confirmation that the early years gave easily and the middle years withhold on purpose.
(For the sibling readings inside this slow-growth cluster: the slow growth Fénelon said doesn’t feel like growth walks the hidden middle in which interior growth is hidden from the one growing, why Fénelon said the Christian’s hardest year is year three walks the dry middle every soul must walk, and Fénelon on the Christian who has stopped feeling anything walks the flattening of feeling and what continues underneath it. For the bridge to Andrew Murray’s neighbouring contemplative thread, the prayer Andrew Murray said most Christians never pray names the surrender-prayer underneath all of Fénelon’s teaching, and what Andrew Murray meant by the deeper Christian life walks the slower Christian life Fénelon would recognise as a near-cousin to his own.)
What changes, slowly
The dryness will not lift on a schedule. Fénelon’s letters do not promise that the warmth returns next month. What changes, over a year of the small daily simple vigilance, is the instrument the soul is using to read its own life. The thermometer is put down. The peace becomes the new reading. The soul that used to ask do I feel close to God today learns to ask, instead, am I still walking — quietly, faithfully, with my eyes on Him. When the answer is yes — and it almost always is, in the soul that has stopped measuring by warmth — the soul is growing, even on the cool mornings.
This is what fenelon spiritual progress actually is. Not the upward graph of felt warmth. The slow widening of the heart’s capacity to love God without payment, to walk in peace inside uncertainty, to keep watch on Him with simple lovely quiet eyes. The growth is mostly invisible to the one growing. That is part of what makes it growth.
A daily home for the practice
The slow practice we just walked has its 140-day form in Bible Study Workbook for Women.
Get Seven Days of Stillness — free
A free gift from Hayley Louisa Mark. A short devotional companion drawn from the 140-Day series — seven passages, seven contemplative practices, sent to your inbox over the coming week.
No noise. No spam. Unsubscribe whenever you wish.
This article opens the François Fénelon reading library on Everspring Press — slow readings of the seventeenth-century French archbishop’s pastoral letters, with the matched journals at the centre of the practice. Everspring is preparing reprints of Fénelon’s correspondence, including Spiritual Progress, for the soul whose growth has gone quiet and is ready, slowly, to be read by a different instrument.
