How to Stop Being Jealous of Others — Augustine on Envy’s Lies
⏱ 12 min read
It happens in small moments. You scroll past her holiday. You hear, in passing, that her marriage is the thing yours hasn’t been in a decade. You notice the promotion that should have been yours. You see the baby announcement from the friend who never wanted children and somehow got them anyway. The reaction in your chest is fast — a low tight thing that you would not call jealousy out loud, because that is not the kind of woman you intended to be. But you know what it is. The chest has been quietly running this same small hot reaction for years, and you have been hiding it from yourself for almost as long, because the woman you wanted to be does not feel this way about her sister, her friend, her cousin, the woman at church whose life looks like the one you were promised.
This essay is not the voice that will scold you for the feeling. The chest is honest. The jealousy is honest. The question of how to stop being jealous is not a question that responds to being shamed at; it responds to being walked slowly by someone who has had the same chest. Augustine — the fourth-century African bishop whose Confessions is the oldest unflinching autobiography of an honest soul we still have — knew this chest better than most. He was, by his own admission, a deeply restless man. His most famous sentence — our heart is restless, until it repose in Thee — is not a poster on a Christian Pinterest board. It is the bottom line he arrived at after walking the long path the rest of this essay is going to walk slowly. The 140-day form of this slow practice has its place in the Devotional for Women in Their 40s, built for the woman whose chest has been holding the comparison reaction for longer than she meant to.
What follows is the slow contemplative version of how to stop being jealous of others. Not the count your blessings — which is a real instruction but is the wrong one for this particular wound — and not the just stop comparing either. The older thing Augustine meant: the slow honest naming of the lies envy tells, and the slower re-rooting of the restless heart in the only place it has been built to rest. (How to pray when God feels far is the sister Augustine essay for the slot when the jealousy has been long enough that prayer itself has thinned, and what is the image of God walks the deeper Augustine grounding the rest of the practice sits on.)
What jealousy actually is, before we name the lies
Jealousy, in the older Christian tradition, is not the same as ordinary wishing. Wishing — I would like that too — is a clean human response to a good thing in someone else’s life. The wishing has no lie underneath it. The wishing can sit comfortably next to genuine gladness for the other person.
Jealousy is a different chest. Jealousy has a lie underneath it. The lie says, her good is somehow my loss. The chest reacts as if the universe is a closed-zero game — as if the joy she just got was, in some quiet way, subtracted from the joy that was meant for you. The reaction is fast because the lie underneath it is well-rehearsed. The lie has been told to you, by the culture, by the comparison habit, by the chronic measuring of your life against other women’s lives, for so long that the chest now believes it without checking.
The other lie underneath the jealousy is that who you are is being decided by how your life looks next to hers. The chest, in the moment of the reaction, is running a small ongoing trial in which your worth is being weighed against her worth, and her good news has just tilted the scales the wrong way. This is the part of the jealousy that hurts most. It is not really about the holiday or the promotion or the baby. It is about the small ongoing fear that her good means something about your worth.
These two lies — her good is my loss and her good is the measure of my worth — are what Augustine, in his long honest examination of his own chest, traced down to the restlessness underneath. He understood, before the language of comparison habit existed, that the jealousy was symptomatic. The cure had to address what the jealousy was pointing at, not the jealousy itself.
The first line — Augustine on the restless heart and where it actually rests
Here is the first of the three passages worth keeping near the page. It is the line everyone has heard a fragment of and almost nobody has read in the full breath Augustine wrote it in:
Thou awakest us to delight in Thy praise; for Thou madest us for Thyself, and our heart is restless, until it repose in Thee.
— Augustine, Confessions
The fragment that has travelled is our heart is restless until it rests in Thee. The fragment is true. The fuller sentence is more useful for the jealousy question, because the fuller sentence names where the restlessness came from — not from a deficit in life, not from a comparison to other women, but from the simple fact that Thou madest us for Thyself.
Augustine’s diagnosis, in this sentence, is that the human chest is restless by design — not by accident, not by personal failure, but because the soul was built to repose in God and has not yet done so. The restlessness is not a defect to be managed; it is a signal, pointing at the place the soul has not yet sat down in.
The reason this matters for the jealousy question is this: the chest that reacts when her good news lands is not reacting because you are a small person. It is reacting because the chest is unsettled, and the unsettled chest reaches, in the moment of unsettlement, for the nearest measurement to tell it what it is worth. The nearest measurement is usually another woman’s life. The comparison reaction is the unsettled chest, doing what the unsettled chest does. The cure is not the suppression of the comparison; the cure is the settling of the chest in the only resting-place it has been built to actually settle in.
How to stop being jealous, on this reading, is in part the slow re-routing of the chest’s unsettled reaching — from the nearest woman’s life back to the only place the restlessness was ever going to come to rest in the first place. The jealousy will quiet to the degree that the restlessness underneath it has found its repose. Not because you have forced yourself to be gladder for her. Because you no longer need her life to tell you what yours is worth.
A pause for the body
Set the screen down for a breath. The body has been carrying the comparison habit longer than the mind has been admitting. Most often, the jealousy reaction lives in a small tightness across the upper chest, sometimes in the throat, sometimes in the shoulders that have been quietly squared as if for inspection. Bring one hand to where the reaction sits. Stay there for one slow inhale and one slow exhale. Do not try to stop comparing in this minute. Do not try to feel gladder for anyone. Let the hand be a small acknowledgement that the body has been measuring itself, too — not just the mind. Let the shoulders lower by an inch. Let the breath come a little slower than it has been coming. The body is allowed, in this minute, to step out of the trial. The chest is allowed to be unmeasured for sixty seconds. The slow undoing of the jealousy starts here — not because anyone has decided the trial is over, but because the body has been told it can stop holding itself up for the verdict for one slow breath.
The second line — Augustine on what the wandering chest is actually wandering from
The second passage is also from the Confessions, and it is the one that names — with the specific honesty Augustine became known for — what happens when the chest goes outward in search of the thing it actually needs inward:
Thou then heldest Thy peace, and I wandered further and further from Thee, into more and more fruitless seed-plots of sorrows, with a proud dejectedness, and a restless weariness.
— Augustine, Confessions
Fruitless seed-plots of sorrows. The image is exact. The jealous chest is planting seeds in plots that will not bear fruit. The comparison reaches outward — to her holiday, her marriage, her promotion, her baby — and tries to sow the unsettlement in soil that cannot grow what the chest is actually hungry for. The result is fruitless — not because the comparison was insufficiently rigorous, but because the soil itself was the wrong soil.
Augustine’s older language for what the unsettled chest is doing — proud dejectedness — is one of the more pastorally useful diagnoses in the Confessions. The chest is proud — that is, it has set itself up as the judge in the small trial of whose life is worth more — and it is also dejected, because the trial keeps coming back with the wrong verdict. Proud dejectedness is the chest of the jealous woman, exactly. The pride is in the trial-running. The dejectedness is in the verdict the trial keeps returning. They are not two reactions but one — held together, as Augustine names them, by the restlessness underneath.
The restless weariness is the fruit. The chest that has been running the trial for years is weary. The comparison habit is exhausting. It costs sleep. It costs joy. It costs the ability to be in the room with the women you actually love. It costs the small bright moments that should have been yours to have, and were instead spent in the small ongoing measurement of your life against other women’s lives.
The slow cure, in Augustine’s reading, is not the application of more willpower to the comparison — more willpower is what has produced the proud dejectedness in the first place — but the slow turning of the chest back toward the place it has been wandering from. The peace is in the return, not in the management. (A beginner study bible for women is the on-ramp for the woman whose returning has been thinned by years of comparing herself to the women who seem to know their Bible, and the older Augustine reading on prayer is here in how to pray when God feels far for the day the return itself feels far.)
This is the slow form of the practice the Devotional for Women in Their 40s was built to walk. Not as a script for instant freedom from comparison, but as a daily small room in which the unsettled chest has a place to sit — five minutes, one verse, one slow prayer — until the fruitless seed-plot has been replaced, one daily page at a time, by the soil the chest was actually planted in.
The third line — Augustine on the soul slowly turned, and what becomes available
The third passage is the one that names — astonishingly briefly, in one sentence — what becomes available to the chest that has slowly let itself be re-turned. It is also from the Confessions:
I trembled for fear, and again kindled with hope, and with rejoicing in Thy mercy, O Father; and all issued forth both by mine eyes and voice, when Thy good Spirit turning unto us, said, O ye sons of men, how long slow of heart?
— Augustine, Confessions
Trembled for fear, and again kindled with hope, and with rejoicing in Thy mercy. The chest that has been re-turned is not a chest that no longer feels anything. It is a chest that has room for trembling, and for kindling, and for rejoicing — sometimes in the same hour. The jealousy reaction was not the only feeling the chest had been having; it had simply been the feeling the chest was loudest about, because the underneath was unsettled.
When the underneath is settled — when the chest has begun, slowly, to repose in the One it was built for — the feelings do not flatten. They differentiate. The trembling is allowed to be trembling. The kindling is allowed to be kindling. The rejoicing in another woman’s good news is allowed to be rejoicing — not as a performance, not because you have forced yourself, but as the natural fruit of a chest that no longer needs her good to mean anything about your worth.
How long slow of heart. The line is tender, not corrective. The Father is not impatient with the slowness. He is naming it the way a parent names a small child’s small fear — gently, in passing, with the same hand still on the back of the head. The slowness in the heart’s turning is allowed. The turning itself is the work.
So — how does one actually stop being jealous?
You stop trying to suppress the reaction. The reaction is honest. The chest is honest. The suppression has been costing you years and has not worked.
You name the lie underneath. Her good is not my loss. Her good is not the measure of my worth. Say it slowly. Say it again tomorrow. The naming will be uneven the first three weeks. It will be more honest the second month.
You let the chest’s unsettlement be the signal it actually is. The restlessness is not a defect — it is the chest pointing at where it has not yet sat down. Augustine’s our heart is restless, until it repose in Thee is the diagnosis. The cure is the repose. The repose is not produced by trying harder at not-comparing; it is produced by the slow daily return to the One the chest was made for.
You walk a small daily practice of the return. Five minutes. The chair. The hand on the chest. One slow prayer. Father, my heart is unsettled. I am letting it be unsettled in Your room rather than in the comparison room. No outcome required. The slow return is the practice; the jealousy quiets at the pace the restlessness eases. (For the daily-page shape of this small practice, a beginner study bible for women and how to pray when God feels far are the on-ramps. For the sister practice with the louder cousin of envy — the long-grown bitterness — Murray’s reading on the root that defiles walks the same slow undoing in a different key, and the practice for the unfinished business with the person who actually hurt you is in hard forgiveness — de Sales.)
You let yourself be slow of heart. How long slow of heart is not a rebuke. It is the Father’s gentle naming. The slowness in the turning is allowed. The turning is the work, and the work is happening, and the small daily practice is enough.
That is the slow Augustine answer. The chest will not be unjealous tomorrow. The reaction will be quieter by the second month. The reposing in the One the chest was built for will begin, in small pieces, to make the comparison reaction less loud. The slow re-rooting is the cure. The forcing of the chest to feel gladder is not the cure, and was never going to be.
Get Seven Days of Stillness — free
A free gift from Hayley Louisa Mark. A short devotional companion drawn from the 140-Day series — seven passages, seven contemplative practices, sent to your inbox over the coming week.
No noise. No spam. Unsubscribe whenever you wish.
The slow practice we just walked has its 140-day form in Devotional for Women in Their 40s.
